Staten Island and the outer boroughs
Staten Island is the city's most conservative borough, and parts of Queens and Brooklyn have strong conservative, church-going neighborhoods, many of them home to police, firefighter and military families.
The Empire State
Conservative Dating New York: Love in the City and Beyond
Eight in ten of our New York members are women, most of them in New York City.
Good news for conservative men in New York
Of the states we cover, New York is where women most clearly outnumber men: about eight in ten of our New York members are women. Most of them live in New York City, and most are between 25 and 44. If you are a conservative man in New York, that is good news for you.
For conservative women in the city, the challenge is the opposite one. Dating in Manhattan or Brooklyn as a Trump voter can be hard going. Maga-Dating lets you meet conservative men, and it pays to look beyond the city.
New York members by age
Women81%
Members aged 25 to 4478%
Members aged 45 or over19%
Members under 254%
Shares of our members in New York State, from our member records.
Nearly one in five New York members is 45 or over.
City, island, upstate
Three different New Yorks
Where conservatives live in New York shapes how you will meet.
Long Island
Nassau and Suffolk counties mix suburban family life with beaches, boating and a large community of first responders.
Upstate and the North Country
From the Hudson Valley to the Finger Lakes, the Adirondacks and Western New York, much of the state is rural and conservative.
New York first dates
- Central Park. A walk, a coffee and a bench by the lake: free, public and easy to stretch out if it is going well.
- Fleet Week in late May, when Navy and Coast Guard ships dock in the city and sailors and Marines come ashore.
- A Finger Lakes winery or a Hudson Valley orchard for apple picking in the fall.
- A Yankees or Mets game, or a high school football game on Long Island.
- The Staten Island Ferry at sunset: free, public and a fine view of the Statue of Liberty.
See first date ideas for conservatives for more.
Look beyond the city
Most of our New York members are in the city, so if you live elsewhere in the state, look beyond your own town. VIP members can search by city and distance; everything is on our pricing page. Neighboring Pennsylvania is worth a look too.
Proud, not quiet
You may have spent years keeping your views to yourself at work and with friends. On Maga-Dating there is no need. Put your values on your profile, say that church matters to you if it does, and mention the things you love about the state, from the Adirondacks to a good slice.
New York dating questions
Can you find conservative singles in New York City?
Yes. Most of our New York members live in the city, and about eight in ten of them are women.
Which part of New York is most conservative?
In the city, Staten Island. Statewide, much of upstate, Long Island's suburbs and the North Country lean conservative.